Homemade Yogurt

Making your own yogurt really isn’t that difficult.  There has been a lot of posts out in the food blog world about making your own and, of course, Mark Bittman has a great bit in his How to Cook Everything Vegetarian. I used the basics from 101 Cookbooks and have been making my own for a while.  Phil posted a pic of the homemade yogurt already, but I thought I would just write out the process and also how to strain yogurt to make Greek-style yogurt.

Homemade Yogurt

Homemade Yogurt


  1. 1 quart of milk (I usually use skim, but used 1% last time and it came out great.  Obviously, the more rich your milk, the more rick your yogurt)
  2. 2-3 tablespoons of Stonyfield Plain Yogurt (lowfat, fullfat, JUST NOT NONFAT)

Good Things to Have:

  • You should also have a food thermometer.  They’re pretty cheap.  Buy one for the upcoming recipe on caramels.
  • A wide-mouth thermos to incubate your yogurt or a yogurt maker is a wise investment if you dig making your own yogurt.  They can be had cheaply on amazon.  I have a Salton that appears to be out of stock forever as it is now $500 (I paid $16 for it).

To Do:

Pour the milk into a microwavable glass bowl.  Microwave for 8 minutes.  You don’t want the milk the boil, but it needs to heat up enough to kill any remaining bacteria.  I usually heat it between 180-185F, which is about 8 minutes in the microwave.  Alternatively, use the double boiler method and stand over the milk and stir it constantly so that it doesn’t scorch.

Take out the bowl of milk and let it hang out until it hits 110-112F.  Don’t let it get under 110!  If you’re in a hurry, put the bowl into an ice water bath (a larger bowl filled with icecubes and cold water) and cool the milk down to 110-112F.  If your Stonyfield yogurt isn’t already on the counter, take it out of the fridge and let it get to room temperature.  Also, preheat your yogurt maker or pour some boiling water in a thermos and keep it hot.

Once the milk hits 110-112F whisk in the yogurt a bit at a time.  Try to make sure the yogurt dissolves in the milk.  Pour into yogurt maker and let sit undisturbed for about 6-8 hours.  The longer the time, the tangier and more solid the yogurt.  *If you’re using a thermos,  empty out the boiled water, shake it vigorously to dry out a bit, add the yogurt mixture and cap tightly.  Wrap in a blanket and keep in a warm, undisturbed place overnight.

The next morning, you should have yogurt!  It might look weird, lots of liquid on top, kinda grainy and smell tangy, but that’s okay!  Stir it all up and put it in a container and leave it in the fridge for a few hours.  It should thicken up.

The yogurt will be less thick than most commercial yogurts because there is no added pectin or other things to solidify it.  I usually make the yogurt, take two tablespoons out to start my next batch (so you don’t have to go out and buy more yogurt!), and strain the remaining yogurt into a thicker yogurt.

How Do I Strain Yogurt?

Easy.  You can use a cheese cloth, coffee filter or some paper towels.  Line a seive with one of the three items I mentioned in the last sentence.  Place seive over another bowl.  Pour yogurt into your lined seive.  Cover with plastic wrap or a damp paper towel or coffee filter.  Leave in fridge for a few hours and up to overnight.  The longer you strain it, the more dense it becomes and forms a type of yogurt “cheese” that you can combine with herbs and use as cream cheese.  I have one of those coffee filters you don’t need a liner for, so I usually use it to strain the yogurt instead of using up paper products, but whatever works!

*I’ve never tried this thermos business, but after reading a bunch of blogs, it appears to work.  For more ideas on how to keep yogurt incubated for the right amount of time and a much more detailed tutorial, go here.

8 Comments on “Homemade Yogurt”

  1. […] to: $14.92.  We have $15.08 to spend (preferably on veggies).  I bought the yogurt (have to start making my own again) to go with the granola we made – perfect […]

  2. seth says:

    My co-op blogged about your blog today, I dig it. A couple of yogurt tips: whisk in a little non-instant powdered milk at the beginning, there’s more stuff for the bacteria to eat so it’s thicker; I heat it a little more, to 190, I forget what the magic temperature is, but it changes the protein structure, making for better texture; I make a well in the finished yogurt, and drink the whey — by the end of the week what’s left is greek yogurt.

  3. […] 1.00 (it’s time to start making some homemade yogurt […]

  4. Jenn says:

    Hey! Do you think it will still work if you substituted soy milk or almond milk ?

  5. Janice Cook says:

    First of all – LOVE this blog. We love to cook and are challenging ourself this month to lower our food bill so this will give us great ideas.

    We started making our own yogurt a month ago and I wanted to say that the instructions say that soy milk can be used. Ours needs to go for 12 hrs in the yogurt maker (for fat free milk) so it’s interesting that yours is done faster.

    Have you ventured into flavoring at all? I’d be curious if you had any tips on that. Also, we currently use paper towels inside a fine mesh sieve but I’m wondering if we need them at all. I don’t like that some of the yogurt gets stuck to it and goes to waste. Could you offer any thoughts on that or maybe post a pic/link to this filterless coffee tool you use. I’d be very interested in improving our straining.

    Thanks again for the great blog!!

    • tinaspins says:

      We highly advise to get a metal/gold sieve. It’s fine enough to let the yogurt drip and not waste any paper products. We weren’t happy with throwing out so much paper, so we got one and it worked great!

  6. Sandy Dunn says:

    I use a thin-old-CLEAN t-shirt in my sieve. I can push thicker material away from the edges (without tearing the filter). The strained yogurt just peels away from the cotton material after sitting for a couple of hours. No waste.
    Love this stuff – and your helpful blogs. Thanks.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s